No where are these sentiments more apparent than in Ars Technica’s blog entry on the subject. First, it's an honor to be mentioned on a site for which I have a great deal of respect. A few of the comments, however, merit a rebuttal...
$500? Anyone with enough talent to do this will feel like there are far more lucrative ways to fill their time.
First, let me say that InsanelyMac does not exist to make money. We have some ads to help cover hosting costs and to do cool contests like this. One of the things I’m committed to with this site is ensuring that building revenue is never annoying. We could offer more if we compromised and made money the driving force behind this community. It's not, however, and we'd like to keep it that way.
Secondly, this is the reason for taking donations. If the community wants this app, they can also assist in its development.
Third, $500 is a great haul for a few hours worth of work.
Finally, the money isn’t the point of the contest. It’s incentive, but the main reasons for this challenge are to allow programmers to show off their coding prowess and have some fun while giving something to the Mac community.
Switchers need to get over it. Mac OS IS NOT Windows. I can live with close button closing something like the Calculator or Network Utility (apps with only 1 window), but I don't want to see this expanded to all multi-window apps. It just would NOT be "Mac-like".
Thus the option for a per application setting. If you only want to change the characteristics of one app, you can.
Most of these "annoyances" are just behaviors of OS X that are different than Windows. The term "fix" generally implies something is broken. Really, a contest like this appearing on a pro Mac website seems a little awkward. This author is forgetting that all apps don’t follow the Apple HIG (as noted in my original post). When inconstancies, like the misuse of the green Zoom button, abound in a user interface, the user suffers.
But that doesn't change the fact that this competition is useless. The buttons work as designed. The thing is, a few apps are not truly following the proper rules (the Finder of course..) There are plenty of other OS X things that are far more annoying.
Useless? I think not. One of the best examples is Activity Monitor. I would love the ability to quit that app when I use the red Close button. What’s wrong with giving me the freedom to do that? Also, we’ll be getting to other annoying (and less controversial) things later on in the contest series.
The point of this challenge is to have fun and give the user more freedom. In the end, is that really a bad thing?
- Read more...
- 11 comments
- 3245 views