35 replies to this topic

[mitch_de]

I made that small OpenGL FPS Bench using franklin3D engine (which uses irrlicht3D engine ).
Its "better" than benching OpenGL by XBench - but as ever not as good as real gaming fps.
Other even more detailed OpenGL Bebch is OpenGLExtensionsViewer
EDIT: updated V 1.3.2, recompiled with newer franklin3d/irrlicht engine
EDIT: removed corrupt (RS LINKED) version, reuploaded to this site internal dl


You may post your results. Better use 1024x768 FPS for compare to others, which cant do your higher res.

Attached Files

•  s2.jpg   397.55K   100 downloads
•  Bildschirmfoto 2012-06-08 um 14.30.48.jpg   173.76K   8 downloads
•  smallOpenGL FPS Bench.zip   9.35MB   51 downloads

Edited by mitch_de, 10 June 2012 - 07:55 AM.

[AppleIIGuy]

A Name of the app / link would help...

[mitch_de]

macupdate has some delay to list my already uploaded smallOpenGL FPS Bench. (happen sometimes with new apps).
I uploaded it also to RS . DL Link in first posting. Also made some minor changes.
Happy Benching
macupdate DL is also available now

[Cyberdog !]

iMac JUN 2010
Core 2 Duo 3.06 Ghz + Nvidia9400
10.6.4 / 4 GO RAM

Scene 1
1024x768   FPS 52  Min 82  Max 148
1440x900   FPS 36  Min 83  Max 121
1680x1050 FPS 30  Min 80  Max 106


Scene 2
1024x768   FPS 165  Min 162  Max 189
1440x900   FPS 108  Min 101  Max 142
1680x1050 FPS  89   Min   98  Max 116

Edit :
the first "iMac JUN 2010" is bad but I don't know why.
I try with Three other "iMac JUN 2010"
post the result .zip in this message

Attached Files

•  3_x_SCENE_1.zip   412.82K   5 downloads
•  6_x_SCENE_2.zip   1.04MB   6 downloads

[mitch_de]

Thanks for first 9400M Results.
Quesition about your posted FPS values:
"1680x1050 FPS 30 Min 80 Max 106"
Do you mean Min 80 / Max 106 ? And what do you mean with 30 ?
Has the permanent changing FPS counter shown that low FPS (or any FPS below 50 FPS) for  longer time?

EDIT: Thanks for screenshoots - problem seen - and fixed  
I updated App to V1.2 -Min FPS counter can now be much less than before. ( 20+ FPS)!
That should fix the wrong(too high)  Min FPS counter for slow GPUs like 9400M or even worst GMA 950.
The changing FPS counter was/is OK (seen at your screenshoots), only that low FPS wasnt used as min FPS, only higher ones.
Happy benching.

[rednous]

mitch, here's my contribution with smallOpenGL FPS Bench v1.2:

System: OS X 10.6.4 x64 > Core 2 Duo @ 2.93GHz > nVidia 9800GT 512 MB > 8GB RAM

OpenGL 2.1, Scene 1:
1024x768 > FPS: 323 Min:265 Max: 473
1440x900 > FPS: 234 Min: 171 Max: 456
1920x1200 > FPS: 222 Min: 197 Max: 411
2560x1440 > FPS: 175 Min: 99 Max: 191

OpenGL 2.1,Scene 2:
1024x768 > FPS: 703 Min:473 Max: 1018
1440x900 > FPS: 643 Min: 398 Max: 704
1920x1200 > FPS: 161 Min: 141 Max: 178
2560x1440 > FPS: 174 Min: 151 Max: 179

I had one app crash while running scene 1 and another one when running scene 2 bench. I've attached the crash report if it could be useful for you to approve the smallOpenGL FPS Bench

[Kappy]

Quote

I made that small OpenGL FPS Bench using franklin3D engine (which uses irrlicht3D engine ).
Its "better" than benching OpenGL by XBench - but as ever not as good as real gaming fps.
Other even more detailed OpenGL Bebch is OpenGLExtensionsViewer (also at macupdate.com).

@ Mitch,

I noted this problem on my computer.  After running a test then stopping by use of ESC, then quitting by use of COMMAND-Q, the app returns a crash error.  The crash report is fairly long.  I've attached it below:

 Crash_report.zip   33.4K   0 downloads

[Cyberdog !]

iMac Core Duo 1.83 Ghz
ATI X1600
10.6.4 / 2GB RAM


Scene 1
1024x768   FPS  34   MIN  24    MAX 41
1440x900   FPS  22   MIN  21    MAX 32

Scene 2
•1024x768
Parallax Mapping   FPS 142  MIN 134   MAX 156
Bump Mapping      FPS 167  MIN 128   MAX 168
Diffuse                  FPS 181  MIN 119   MAX 188

•1440x900
Parallax Mapping   FPS   97  MIN   92   MAX 100
Bump Mapping      FPS 114  MIN   92   MAX 136
Diffuse                 FPS 158  MIN 110   MAX 165

[makkernel2]

Thanks mitch

[mitch_de]

"I had one app crash while running scene 1 and another one when running scene 2 bench. I've attached the crash report if it could be useful for you to approve the smallOpenGL FPS Bench"
Thanks !
The crash (a also have 1/2 times on Quit the app) is known. Must be some problem with the 3Dengine which get not quit like it should.

Or did the bench crash while the bench is running (Before you ESC / Quit the app)?

[rednous]

mitch_de, on Aug 13 2010, 09:24 AM, said:

"I had one app crash while running scene 1 and another one when running scene 2 bench. I've attached the crash report if it could be useful for you to approve the smallOpenGL FPS Bench"
Thanks !
The crash (a also have 1/2 times on Quit the app) is known. Must be some problem with the 3Dengine which get not quit like it should.

Or did the bench crash while the bench is running (Before you ESC / Quit the app)?

The first crash was during the bench and the second one quitting the application. Unfortunately, I didn't save the first crash report.

[mitch_de]

UPDATE to V1.3.1

[@ROBASEFR]

Here ara my results for ATI4850GS-512Mo card under 10.6.5 with OpenGL 2.1 -1.6.24 Pro engine renderer

2560x1440  
Scene1= 61 FPS
Scene2= 61 FPS

1024x768
Scene1=356 FPS
Scene2= 1271 FPS

[mitch_de]

thanks - perhaps soon others / Fermi GTX 4xx ?

[quattrofx]

Hi mitch_de,

My scores with gtx 285 (Signature):

Scene 1
1024x768-----------MIN 398 MAX 465
1680x1050--------- MIN 168 MAX 180

Scene 2
---------------------------------1024x768-------------------1680x1050
Parallax Mapping---MIN 1108 MAX 1120------------- MIN 242 MAX 247
Bump Mapping-----MIN 1101 MAX 1126------------- MIN 242 MAX 251
Diffuse --------------MIN 1101 MAX 1300------------- MIN 242 MAX 260

Cheers
QuattroFX

[mlstudio]

Hello,

Here are the results for NVIDIA GT220 1GB DDR3 on Intel Quad Q8400 2.66GHz (fake MacPro 3.1)

Scene 1

1024x768     FPS 212 Min 168 Max 324
1440x900     FPS 166 Min 127 Max 165

Scene 2 Diffuse:

1024x768     FPS 670 Min 469 Max 670
1440x900     FPS 581 Min 376 Max 594

Scene 2 Bump Mapping:

1024x768     FPS 593 Min 470 Max 618
1440x900     FPS 418 Min 365 Max 424     

Scene 2 Parallax Mapping:

1024x768     FPS 541 Min 471 Max 548
1440x900     FPS 409 Min 378Max 420

[akiNikki]

So this not working on 450GTS right? Cause nothing happen when I pressed start, it making my mouse unusable.

[mitch_de]

Yep, it can be some problem which OpenGL calls are used by the irrlicht 3d engine (is used as 3D unit) - dont worry about that if your real games work or OpenGLExtensionsviewer* works as benchmark!


Also dont forget to try GRASS (its OpenCL - compute on GPU) - at least non hal100 (NV 4xx) cards should work with OpenCL.

* since last major Update the OpenGLExtensionsviewer got more "real game testing" if you use the new +huge 3D Object King insted of known CUBE (much simplier than KING).
Problem of really valide OEV tests is the huge configurability (Multisamling, Anithros, one Object vs many objects (KING vs KINGS))
To compare GPUs on complete different computers/screens better use:
resolution up to 1280x1024 (1440x900), windowed (fullscreen off , that disables also VSYNC!!!) , Multisampling * 2, Anithros * 8 and single Objects (KING or CUBE, not KINGS or CUBES).
Many Objects KINGS, CUBES is even more real game test, BUT cpu usage is also much higher = faster cpu gives much faster FPS with same gpu.
If you want compare OpenGL driver speed diffs (by OS X updates) on YOUR computer , its best to reduce GPU load to measure the (most) little driver speed diffs:
windowed up to 800x 600, multisamling off, anitros off

We can also use that thread now collecting here also OpenGLExtensionsviewer tests.
Beside my hint to use the above (first) listed config for OGLEV, you can post also you fullscreen FPS (same other config, but highest res  of your monitor).

[akiNikki]

I can't open the Grass Test my friend. It says my MAC version is not supported. Running 10.6.5 here.

[mitch_de]

akiNikki, on Dec 3 2010, 09:29 AM, said:

I can't open the Grass Test my friend. It says my MAC version is not supported. Running 10.6.5 here.

Happens if the GPU Type is not (already) supported. Seems that only CUDA already works not OpenCL with NV 4xx GPUs.