Jump to content
zhell

DVD burner may cause sleep on idle to fail

31 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

DVD Burner May Be Cause of Insomnia

 

It has been reported by Master Chief that (i) his DVD drive starts to make funny noises when the machine should be going to sleep and (ii) that this madness can be stopped by simply putting DVD into he drive.

 

I found unplugging the drive also did the trick, but that's kind of inconvenient.

 

Since I wanted to get rid of my crappy TSST (Samsung Toshiba Storage Technology) SH-223 drive anyway, I thought what the heck, if DSDT cannot fix it, let hardware to it. So I got myself a nice Optiarc AD-7243 dvd drive and replaced the TSST one.

 

'Lo and behold, sleep on idle works now :)

 

However, I cannot spot any difference in System Profiler or IORegistryExplorer between the drives. This leads me to believe it's simply a bug in the drive.

Before you run out and get a new DVD drive, please note that with 10a380, sleep on idle also works properly with the TSST drive.

 

Please report what drive you have and whether or not sleep works.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement
DVD Burner May Be Cause of Insomnia

 

It has been reported by Master Chief that (i) his DVD drive starts to make funny noises when the machine should be going to sleep and (ii) that this madness can be stopped by simply putting DVD into he drive.

 

I found unplugging the drive also did the trick, but that's kind of inconvenient.

 

Since I wanted to get rid of my crappy TSST (Samsung Toshiba Storage Technology) SH-223 drive anyway, I thought what the heck, if DSDT cannot fix it, let hardware to it. So I got myself a nice Optiarc AD-7243 dvd drive and replaced the TSST one.

 

'Lo and behold, sleep on idle works now :)

 

However, I cannot spot any difference in System Profiler or IORegistryExplorer between the drives. This leads me to believe it's simply a bug in the drive.

Before you run out and get a new DVD drive, please note that with 10a380, sleep on idle also works properly with the TSST drive.

 

Please report what drive you have and whether or not sleep works.

 

I have this drive too! I've been pulling my hair out thinking it was my OS X install. I think I may just get a couple new optical drives and fix it that way. However I have upgraded the firmware to SB03 to see if perhaps that'll fix it. I'll post my results.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What if I don't even have a DVD Drive?

I only have 2 Sata HDD's, and I can't get auto sleep to work =/

Sleep works if I induce it myself, and it wakes fine too, actually no. For some reason it kept launching the Bluetooth Setup Assistant after waking lol.

 

EDIT:

I am really surprised that I also have the dvd drive - sleep on idle bug. I didn't think this was possible, seeing as I use a USB/external drive to install (Which does happen to be a Samsung drive!) and I leave it off after the OS is installed. But nevertheless, I tried inserting a DVD (an actual dvd, DVD app pops up telling me it can't find suitable dvd drive), and YES, it did sleep on idle! I'm not sure what I can do to correct this. I mean, the drive is not even connected and it still won't sleep on idle! - I prefer not to have a DVD drive connected to the system through internal SATA, I don't want to dedicate space/power to something I only use for OS installs.

 

EDIT2:

Disabling sleep for hard drives in Energy Saver pref pane works!

Thanks Beerkex'd!

 

Yet Another Edit:

After a reinstall, this time installing from existing install, so no dvd drive was ever used, and I have yet to plug one in for the OS to recognize, Sleep on idle not working. I wonder if connecting the usb one to sort of get it going would work...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@zhell

 

I have the SH-223 drive you have (SATA). 10.6 didn't fix this, at least not with my DSDT. The old solution of leaving a disk in the drive works though. We also noticed that changing to a Pioneer drive fixed the issue. Glad you are confirming that the Sony Optiarchs work also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all

 

So nice to find at least an answer to this blocking point!

 

I have a Samsun SH203 DVD drive and can't reach sleep on idle neither with OSX 10.5.85, nor with 10.6.1. I already noticed, though, that my 10.5.8 install unexpectedly reached sleep on idle after creating a disk image. I just went away, living the image creation going on, and the PC was 'sleeping' when I came back but I couldn't reproduce it anymore.

 

I will retry this: leaving intentionally a disk in my DVD drive and double check.

I will also try 'disabling sleep for hard drives in Energy Saver pref pane' and tell you what the result is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi all

 

So nice to find at least an answer to this blocking point!

 

I have a Samsun SH203 DVD drive and can't reach sleep on idle neither with OSX 10.5.85, nor with 10.6.1. I already noticed, though, that my 10.5.8 install unexpectedly reached sleep on idle after creating a disk image. I just went away, living the image creation going on, and the PC was 'sleeping' when I came back but I couldn't reproduce it anymore.

 

I will retry this: leaving intentionally a disk in my DVD drive and double check.

I will also try 'disabling sleep for hard drives in Energy Saver pref pane' and tell you what the result is.

 

 

Also try unplugging the power from the DVD burner to see if it'll sleep on it own.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Also try unplugging the power from the DVD burner to see if it'll sleep on it own.

 

Too Bad!

I couldn't get the sleep on idle to work even when I unplugged my DVD drive, neither on 10.5.7, nor on 10.6.1. Sleep for hardrive disabled didn't change anything neither :thumbsup_anim:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DVD Burner May Be Cause of Insomnia

 

It has been reported by Master Chief that (i) his DVD drive starts to make funny noises when the machine should be going to sleep and (ii) that this madness can be stopped by simply putting DVD into he drive.

 

I found unplugging the drive also did the trick, but that's kind of inconvenient.

 

Since I wanted to get rid of my crappy TSST (Samsung Toshiba Storage Technology) SH-223 drive anyway, I thought what the heck, if DSDT cannot fix it, let hardware to it. So I got myself a nice Optiarc AD-7243 dvd drive and replaced the TSST one.

 

'Lo and behold, sleep on idle works now :D

 

However, I cannot spot any difference in System Profiler or IORegistryExplorer between the drives. This leads me to believe it's simply a bug in the drive.

Before you run out and get a new DVD drive, please note that with 10a380, sleep on idle also works properly with the TSST drive.

 

Please report what drive you have and whether or not sleep works.

 

Hi there Zhell

 

the same no auto sleep problem with proper dsdt

autosleep works when disconnected or with dvd in the drive

 

Dvd type is TSST SH-S183A

 

already orded the Optiarc AD-7243 drive

report back later

 

Thnx

T.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi there Zhell

 

the same no auto sleep problem with proper dsdt

autosleep works when disconnected or with dvd in the drive

 

Dvd type is TSST SH-S183A

 

already orded the Optiarc AD-7243 drive

report back later

 

Thnx

T.

 

That will, almost assuredly, fix your sleep problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That will, almost assuredly, fix your sleep problem.

 

thnx Kdawg,

got the dvd burner in today and i can confirm auto sleep is working

but one question does your drive also makes a lot of noise when the tray opens without a disc?

 

T.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi.

My DVD burner is an LG HL-DT-ST DVDRAM GH20NS10.

Auto sleep doesn't work and disabling sleep for hard drive doesn't fix it. With this option enabled looks like the DVD drive is accessed every minute or so (makes noise and LED blinks), but disabling it doesn't fix auto sleep.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
thnx Kdawg,

got the dvd burner in today and i can confirm auto sleep is working

but one question does your drive also makes a lot of noise when the tray opens without a disc?

 

T.

 

 

Yes, mine is crazy loud. Glad you posted. Must be normal :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
the same no auto sleep problem with proper dsdt

 

"proper dsdt"?

 

Is there an explicit DSDT fix for this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
thnx Kdawg,

got the dvd burner in today and i can confirm auto sleep is working

but one question does your drive also makes a lot of noise when the tray opens without a disc?

 

T.

 

Yeah, unfortunately it is noisier. I'll take the lesser of two evils though.

 

"proper dsdt"?

 

Is there an explicit DSDT fix for this?

 

I don't think so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi.

The guys who have Optiarc AD-7243, what do you see in System Profiler for your drive? Is there an "Async Notification" information?

Thank you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yeah, unfortunately it is noisier. I'll take the lesser of two evils though.

 

Ok, nice to know it's normal...!!

thnx

 

T.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh, WOW. I've been tearing my hair out over this one. Reinstalled several times, waiting ages between each step and couldn't figure out just when the disc noise started happening!! I'm so glad I know what it is now!

 

i have a LiteOn DVD writer. I know, I never heard of them either, dunno how I ended up with it. One minute I was at the counter next minute I was walking out with the box tucked under my arm. I suspect hypnosis.

 

Anyway other than putting a disc in the drive or disconnecting, anyone got a fix for this yet?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe its the "Power off" not being supported that causes this?

 

A real macbook with nvidia chipset has the following (I found it on the internet):

 

MAT{censored}ADVD-R UJ-868:

 

Model: MAT{censored}ADVD-R UJ-868

Revision: KA14

Native Command Queuing: No

Detachable Drive: No

Power Off: Yes

Async Notification: No

 

 

On my hackintosh with a LG drive I have the following:

 

HL-DT-ST DVDRAM GH22NS40:

 

Model: HL-DT-ST DVDRAM GH22NS40

Revision: NL01

Native Command Queuing: No

Detachable Drive: No

Power Off: No

Async Notification: No

Bay Name: Bay 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Strange ... My TSST (Samsung Toshiba Storage Technology) SH-223 doesn't seem to cause any sleep problems. This is true with or without a disk in it.

 

TSSTcorp CDDVDW SH-S223F:

 

Capacity: 584.1 MB (584,122,368 bytes)

Model: TSSTcorp CDDVDW SH-S223F

Revision: SB03

Serial Number:

Native Command Queuing: No

Removable Media: Yes

Detachable Drive: No

BSD Name: disk3

Power Off: No

Async Notification: Yes

Partition Map Type: APM (Apple Partition Map)

S.M.A.R.T. status: Not Supported

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just to add to the list

 

SAMSUNG TS-H663B/UOAH SATA will not sleep without a disc inserted

 

(I have not tried just disabling HD sleep yet)

 

lite-on DH-20A4H PATA will not properly wake up (goes into an endless loop trying to read the inserted CD)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×