Jump to content
Jordan Davis

Need Advice - Building a Bad Ass Video Editing Computer (OSX)

9 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

I'm a software developer, and have been getting into a lot of photo/video-ography. So I'm looking for advice from the community to help me build bad ass video editing comp so I don't waste my life in front of the screen waiting on rendering times.

 

So I've watched this video --  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SY_h_W5I0Jo&t=497s

  • Looks like in terms of video editing using software like PR and AE, the amount of CPU cores seems to be the greatest factor and the amount of GPU cores coming in 2nd?

 

Build: (keep in mind I want to run OSX)

  • CPU - So I'm looking at getting the new Intel i9? (because the amount of cores)
  • GPU - some high core Radeon GPU? (because I think all apple stuff works with Radeon)
  • FAN - cooler master, idk is this a reliable brand? 
  • idk what  else open for suggestions

 

 

Edited by Jordan Davis
for descriptive title

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement
8 hours ago, Jordan Davis said:

Looks like in terms of video editing using software like PR and AE

Sorry but a very basic question, if you want to run PR and AE then why you need a Hackintosh as those applications run in Windows the same? i9 is an expensive CPU so you can make the best use of it under Windows as Apple has no official support for the desktop version yet, last time I checked some people could run it under macOS but with 6 cores recognized not 8 (idk if that has changed now).

 

If you'd run FCPX which is also very good piece of software then maybe yes its worth the try, otherwise ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, think that’s because the only i9 at the mo is a MacBook Pro with 6 cores


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

AfterEffects doesn't do well with more than ~12 cores. Premiere can use far more.

 

Yes, you probably want to go with an i9, but will need some serious cooling. I'd recommend a 360mm AIO liquid cooler. Fractal design makes an inexpensive one, or Corsair of course.

 

The 1080 Ti is still the fastest card for AE/Premiere, but obviously there is no 10.14 support yet (and if it does come then you would probably want a RTX 2xxx series card).

 

An AMD card would make things easier though, and still be plenty fast in most cases.

 

Most X299 motherboards work, but I would recommend ASRock if you don't need too many bells and whistles, or ASUS if you don't mind spending a bit more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, RandomTech said:

Sorry but a very basic question, if you want to run PR and AE then why you need a Hackintosh as those applications run in Windows the same? i9 is an expensive CPU so you can make the best use of it under Windows as Apple has no official support for the desktop version yet, last time I checked some people could run it under macOS but with 6 cores recognized not 8 (idk if that has changed now).

 

If you'd run FCPX which is also very good piece of software then maybe yes its worth the try, otherwise ?

i9 CPUs work fine. Not sure where you are getting your info, but they worked pretty much since they day they came out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, maleorderbride said:

The 1080 Ti is still the fastest card for AE/Premiere

Do you have any source for that? Because (not officially supported) GTX cards works the same as AMD cards for Pr and Ae and even a bit less after watching this video:

 

 

16 hours ago, maleorderbride said:

Not sure where you are getting your info

From internet, do you have better place to suggest ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, RandomTech said:

Do you have any source for that? Because (not officially supported) GTX cards works the same as AMD cards for Pr and Ae and even a bit less after watching this video:

 

 

From internet, do you have better place to suggest ?

 

I would recommend a website that specializes in pro apps instead of one with a 15 minute ad by Linus for Blue Apron: https://www.pugetsystems.com/labs/articles/Premiere-Pro-CC-2018-NVIDIA-GeForce-vs-AMD-Radeon-Vega-1206/

 

The link to Linus you posted doesn't have Vega or GTX 10xx series cards in it. Why is that relevant in almost 2019? Anyway, a Vega 64 doesn't match a GTX 1080 Ti in anything compute (other than OpenCL vs OpenCL of course), so between worse all around performance and 37.5% less VRAM there isn't much to think about.

 

As for how one might know that i9 2066 CPUs work fine with MacOS--you might try this very website that you are looking at right now. If you can't even run a search on InsanelyMac then I'm not sure why you think you should be giving advice to this guy.

Edited by maleorderbride

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, maleorderbride said:

The link to Linus you posted doesn't have Vega or GTX 10xx series cards in it. Why is that relevant in almost 2019? Anyway, a Vega 64 doesn't match a GTX 1080 Ti in anything compute (other than OpenCL vs OpenCL of course), so between worse all around performance and 37.5% less VRAM there isn't much to think about.

 

As for how one might know that i9 2066 CPUs work fine with MacOS--you might try this very website that you are looking at right now. If you can't even run a search on InsanelyMac then I'm not sure why you think you should be giving advice to this guy.

This is how a typical fanboy changes the whole conversation into a specific hardware against another, GTX 1080 is slightly faster in Adobe but Vega is faster on anything else on Hackintosh running Apple macOS also more Hackintosh friendly, don't forget our topic is about Hackintosh, so as the Linus (old) video showed everyone it doesn't matter if AMD or Nvidia, it all depend on how beefy the GPU is (as he declares at the end as conclusion). of course usd800 would slightly faster than usd500 GPU in Adobe, but is it worth it to pay extra usd300 for a tiny difference? Only Jordan Davis have the answer, not you or me.

 

Also what I see worthless from you is to suggest someone a not Hackintosh friendly GPU like GTX 1080ti for a Hackintosh, as you have one you already know what GTX 10xx and Hackintosh huge amount of problems are , so I'm not going into details and that Nvidia that fake Webdriver issues and its obvious because Apple don't support GTX 1080ti for macOS. please don't remind me my nightmares back then when I had GTX 980ti in my Hackintosh.

 

About the CPU, as I said ''last I checked (idk if that has changed now)'' doesn't mean is a fact as I'm writing it clearly and giving the person a chance to do his in depth research to find better informations (as my sentence was about doubting, nothing fact) anyone could understand that, but not you? Ok I see why.

 

We are already off topic now and I feel ashamed to face a fanboy with low level of mentality into discourse something and feel sorry for Jordan Davis who opened this topic, that's why I will totally ignore you so don't waste my time even more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, RandomTech said:

This is how a typical fanboy changes the whole conversation into a specific hardware against another, GTX 1080 is slightly faster in Adobe but Vega is faster on anything else on Hackintosh running Apple macOS also more Hackintosh friendly, don't forget our topic is about Hackintosh, so as the Linus (old) video showed everyone it doesn't matter if AMD or Nvidia, it all depend on how beefy the GPU is (as he declares at the end as conclusion). of course usd800 would slightly faster than usd500 GPU in Adobe, but is it worth it to pay extra usd300 for a tiny difference? Only Jordan Davis have the answer, not you or me.

 

Also what I see worthless from you is to suggest someone a not Hackintosh friendly GPU like GTX 1080ti for a Hackintosh, as you have one you already know what GTX 10xx and Hackintosh huge amount of problems are , so I'm not going into details and that Nvidia that fake Webdriver issues and its obvious because Apple don't support GTX 1080ti for macOS. please don't remind me my nightmares back then when I had GTX 980ti in my Hackintosh.

 

About the CPU, as I said ''last I checked (idk if that has changed now)'' doesn't mean is a fact as I'm writing it clearly and giving the person a chance to do his in depth research to find better informations (as my sentence was about doubting, nothing fact) anyone could understand that, but not you? Ok I see why.

 

We are already off topic now and I feel ashamed to face a fanboy with low level of mentality into discourse something and feel sorry for Jordan Davis who opened this topic, that's why I will totally ignore you so don't waste my time even more.

 

Get some help man. I said:

"The 1080 Ti is still the fastest card for AE/Premiere, but obviously there is no 10.14 support yet (and if it does come then you would probably want a RTX 2xxx series card).

An AMD card would make things easier though, and still be plenty fast in most cases." That's a direct quote from my first post in this thread.


These are all factual statements. The 1080 Ti is the fastest card for Premiere & AE. If one wants to build a "bad ass video editing computer" then that would be the logical choice. I even specifically mention that an AMD is also a reasonable choice as it can be easier and still fast enough for most people. I'm not sure how accusing someone of being a "fanboy" is a relevant response to inconvenient facts.

 

The GTX 1080 Ti has problems with OpenCL (use CUDA instead, of course), and no support in 10.14 at this time. However, it is grossly mistaken to say a GTX 1080 Ti has a "huge amount of problems." Just as you have been mistaken to say that only six cores of an i9 CPU work in MacOS, and just as you have been mistaken to say that an "A GTX card works the same as AMD for Premiere/AE, and even a bit less." You are clearly quite ignorant about hackintoshes, so I don't understand why you are here giving advice instead of reading the forum boards and perhaps learning something.

 

I understand I hurt your feelings by critiquing your words harshly. Sorry about that. 

Edited by maleorderbride

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

Announcements

  • Similar Content

    • By Isptn
      Hi I am newbie to Mac development and currently trying to get info whether a display is captured, I found such info in doc: CGDisplayIsCaptured(_:).
      https://developer.apple.com/documentation/coregraphics/1562061-cgdisplayiscaptured.
      But this one is deprecated. How can I find out whether a display is captured in other way?
      The goal is: The app should be visible only for user not for those, who see shared screen. So II need to blur the app on screen capture or send notification to user that screen is currently capturing, so I need to know which event cold notify me about that.
    • By Rohan20
      Opencore is running really really slow on Catalina 10.15.4. So It was running perfectly before I put the ssdt-pnlf for enabling Brightness control. it is running really slow and I verified my config with the sanity checker and its all correct. can someone please help. I am attaching my oc folder.

       
      https://www.dropbox.com/s/drkek0eaz19ina5/OC.zip?dl=0
       
    • By Georgiles
      Laptop: Asus Vivobook F510UA
      CPU: Intel Core i5-8250U
      Graphic: Intel UHD 620
      Wifi: Intel Dual Band Wireless-AC 8265 (no kexts for intel wifi) :(
      Card Reader: Realtek_CardReader(RTL8411B_RTS5226_RTS5227)
      Camera: ASUS UVC HD 7.Audio: Conexant Audio CX8050
      Touchpad: ELAN1300
       
       by parkrypto: thank you tctien342 for the amazing guide.
       
      https://github.com/tctien342/Asus-Vivobook-S510UA-High-Sierra-10.13-Hackintosh
       
      Ebayed the laptop for $290 + tax = $350
      added: 16gb RAM + existing 8GB = 24GB          Timetec Hynix IC 16GB DDR4 2400MHz PC4-19200 Non ECC Unbuffered 1.2V CL17 2Rx8 Dual Rank 260 Pin SODIMM Laptop Notebook Computer Memory Ram Module Upgrade S Series (16GB)     
      added: cheap wifi         TP-Link USB Wifi Adapter for PC N150 Wireless Network Adapter for Desktop - Nano Size Wifi Dongle Compatible with Windows 10/7/8/8.1/XP/Vista Mac OS 10.9-10.15 Linux Kernel 2.6.18-4.4.3 (TL-WN725N)     
      added: NAND 1TB Internal PC SSD https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B073SB2MXT/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01_s01?ie=UTF8&psc=1
      Gadget Reviews upgraded too, video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39EquX5PTkQ
       
      I just installed. Everything works fine. I'll test final cut pro, premiere pro with 4k footage and get back with you on performance. 
      For now moves like a performant Mac book pro. 
      I installed Catalina first but I could not make the Intel UHD 620 Graphics get proper QE/CI. 
      Mojave is just fine. I want to use this system for quick video editing on the go.
      Geekbench in my signature.  
      If you need any files or have any questions pls ask.
       






      asus f510u mojave.zip
    • By JoelChris
      Hi guys! I really need help right now.
      So I've just updated my Hackintosh to Catalina 10.15.3 with these following specs,

      Z390 Designare
      Core i9 9900k
      RX 590 Nitro + 8gb Gold Edition
      32 GB ram of Corsair RGB Pro

      After the update, I tried to boot and it's a black screen after loading.
      I also have recently updated the WEG and Lilu, but there's nothing new. It's still stuck with a black screen.

      I have attached my Clover below..
      CLOVER.zip
      Please help and Thankyou so much!
    • By miki971
      Hi, i have a problem with x299 build.
       
      I have 2 Vega 64. With one i have no problems, with 2 i can't have output.
       
      The CPU is i9 7920x.
       
      Can you help me? 
×