Jump to content
XRaidAlex

XSERVE RAID MOD the Ultimate NAS

19 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Hello Folks,

Almost a year ago. I read a forum post on another website of of a guy named xxredxpandaxx modding an old apple XRAID. Essentially Gutting the unit and painstakingly soldering sata through the mother board to allows the caddies to hold SATA drives. It was a great idea and it got me thinking of undertaking such a task. I however have no soldering skills. And with say 14X 8TB I don't trust my soldering when data is at stake. Also nothing on the outside was functional. It was just a case mod, nothing more.

 

Link provided https://forums.lime-technology.com/topic/29324-unraiding-an-apple-xserve-raid/

 

SO I had an idea, redesign boards for both the XRAID and the Caddies. So that at least the drive lights worked in front of the caddy.

 

If you are having a hard time picturing this I will provide pictures.

 

But basically my idea entailed making a Daughter card which would accept multple sata and power wires from a mother board and power supply and then transfer the leads through the XRAID style connectors (SCSI 80) into the Caddy and then back to a sata connector to use with sata drives inside the caddy. I wanted the lights to also be functional.

 

Again I hit a road block I don't know much about making PCB boards. So I enlisted the help and expertise of another forum member, an electrical engineer. Not only was he able to make new caddy boards for SATA, and make the large daughter board to accept the sata from a pc motherboard. He also was able to get the caddy lights to be functional.

 

So the caddies are done. We are now in the final stages of the large 17" daughter board. I will also have pictures of the progress.

 

The third task which will be started soon is getting the throughput lights to work in the center of the machine. My hope is to have it register network bandwidth. Also rewiring of the power button from the back to the front is also on the list.

 

The second part of this project is aesthetics and airflow. I again have no knowledge of how to cut aluminum or design mother board trays. So I enlisted help from someone in the UK. And let me tell you he designed the most beautiful pc tray and top. The tray will have holes for risers for mitx, or matx. and the top will have a cutout that will make it easy to swap cards out so you dont have to unscrew everything to get to them.

 

I will have more pictures and will be editing this post to make it a little bit more linear.

 

I think this will be the best looking NAS out there. Perfect for holding all your data and transcoding plex videos provided you buy enough horsepower under the hood.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

Video of led lights working:

The first photo shows the caddy with its plastic on top.

The second photo shows the new improved sata caddy board.

The third photo shows the 2nd revision of the new 17" board. The 3rd revision containes cut outs for powered fans for pasthru airflow.

If anybody is interested kits will be for sale.

post-1778331-0-99480100-1489632051_thumb.jpg

post-1778331-0-35149900-1489632087_thumb.jpg

post-1778331-0-88755900-1489632118_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thank you... i am looking forward to finally having a large raid that looks amazing, and works flawlessly.

 

As for cost, i will let the talented engineer give his input.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

pm made public for the engineer

 

I got inspired by the limetech forum post as well and am in the process of modding hdd caddies right now. I found your project and have to say: nice job so far.

How did you get the hdd LEDs to work and are they Drive specific; 

Will all activity leds on all drives blink simultaniously or (hopefully ) per disk?

 

And may i add some ideas?

1. You could make the ventilation holes bigger to allow for more airflow. 

2. Relocate the sata Ports to the top to allow for atx mainboards to be installed.

2.a if possible: group all the sata ports to the left or right side of the pcb to reduce cable mess. In Blocks of 4x sata for 8087 mini sas to sata cables

3. include mounting holes for 80mm fans (hole for pcb standoff attached to the Fan).

 

If it helps i could model it in sketchup how i imagine 'my version' of backplane. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The engineer wil explain that the caddy led's will all be independant and functional. If the drive is be accessed it will blink, with activity of the led directly proportional to the activity of the drive.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

See my answers in bold.  

 

Due to the amount of time it will take to assemble the kits and the cost of components we plan to ask for $1000 for a complete kit.

 

This seems like a lot, but in reality a 14 bay Raid does not come cheap in any current form.  

 

pm made public for the engineer

 

I got inspired by the limetech forum post as well and am in the process of modding hdd caddies right now. I found your project and have to say: nice job so far.

How did you get the hdd LEDs to work and are they Drive specific; 

 

The sata power connector on most drives has a pin that is connected to an open drain output to indicate drive activity.   This pin is usually just lumped in with the grounds and not broken out.   I found a cable that has this pin broken out to use an activity light.   I'm not sure how many drives have this pin as i have limited number of drives to try.  I have read that it is usually there. 

Will all activity leds on all drives blink simultaniously or (hopefully ) per disk?

 

Activity indication is per disk.

 

And may i add some ideas?

1. You could make the ventilation holes bigger to allow for more airflow. 

 

This was my original idea, but we decided to make them the right size for 15mm fans.  We will have to revisit this if the fans do not move enough air.

2. Relocate the sata Ports to the top to allow for atx mainboards to be installed.

 

The ports were put where they are to keep the runs as short as possible.  We are already passing the SATA data through a lot of connectors.  I wanted to do as much as possible to help maintain data integrity.  

 

2.a if possible: group all the sata ports to the left or right side of the pcb to reduce cable mess. In Blocks of 4x sata for 8087 mini sas to sata cables

 

Same as above.

 

3. include mounting holes for 80mm fans (hole for pcb standoff attached to the Fan).

 

I like this idea if i can manage to make them line up in a way to not interfere with anything else.

 

If it helps i could model it in sketchup how i imagine 'my version' of backplane. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome Prs-tech... gents and ladies... this is the genius behind the board. Many engineering firms said it couldn't be done.... prs-tech, said to me... "i think i understand what you are trying to do... send me a few caddies, let me take a look. And a few months later here we are!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"$1000 for a complete kit."

 

What does that include?

 

Backplane board, Caddy boards, and Caddy power cable/sata cables.  

Blank boards or solder it yourself kits could be offered for much less.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's quite a lot. more than i would be willing to spend to be honest.

How much would the Diy kits be?

I would prefer to solder them myself

 

Right now i have 2 whole chassis here, 3 original backplanes and 40 caddies. 

And i was originally planning to get at least 2 whole systems complete in the foreseeable future

 

I did a little modelling in sketchup and Fusion 360 for ventilation holes and fan placement.

 

http://imgur.com/a/wYBAs

 

Maybe you can give me some feedback whether or not this design is possible.

I will make an acrylic version of it on my cnc in a few days.

 

I intend on using 5x 80mm Noctua fans so the whole unit doesn't have to be louder than the HDDs themselves

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just posting to express my interest in this project as well.  Would love to hear about any additional progress made (on here or the laserhive blog),

 

I'm in a similar situation with randomguy - I recently picked up 3 chassis that I'm looking to reuse.  Not adverse to soldering myself if it reduces the cost.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry guys, Not a ton of progress right now. the system is pretty close to being done to begin testing. As you can tell form the videos and pictures , it works. Just need to run high speed traffic on it and verify reliablity. from there its just adding bells and whistles. Progress has been slow as i've been insanely busy. work, kids, new baby on the way. Im going to try to get the rest of the caddy boards built and see what i can do about getting a bill of materials ready and order enough boards to sell blank boards for the DIY crowd.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have 4 XRaids.

This tickles my fancy!

I'm happy to PayPal for 4 kits so do please keep us up to date.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just found a Xserve with rails and fiber channel cards and cables. What a deal. There's not even a bid on it yet. Would this work for this project? https://www.k-bid.com/auction/24748

 

JAD77

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By powerpcme
      I updated this Xserve to 10.12.2 using the patcher tool, It worked successfully however the integrated graphics no longer work due to driver issues. I installed a low-profile Nvidia GT 210 and installed drivers for it and it works perfectly. The problem is the ATI x1300 which is integrated in the machine is acting as if the monitor is plugged into it so when I VNC or Screen share from my Macbook into it, it shows 2 screens and has major lag issues due to that. Is there anyway I can disable the ATI?? 
       
      EDIT: I've found a solution for anyone looking. Either using SwitchRezX for a less permanent solution or removing the X1300 from just under the PCI-E slot where the mini DVI is found. Did the latter and it's working fine now, However if you plan on doing OS upgrades that require you to get into the boot menu you're going to have to put the old card back in and use Mini DVI.
    • By enjoyfebruary
      I am considering developing a kit to convert the aging Xserve Raid rack into a useable enclosure. You can now routinely find these units on eBay for around $100, and considering the cost of typical rack unit (which aren't even as nice), I thought it would be about time to look at repurposing this beautifully made case into something builders could recycle. Basically this kit would include replacement PCBs for the drive sleds so that we can use standard SATA drives, while retaining both the power and activity lights. Secondly the kit would include a backplane PCB with standard molex and SAS connections. This would make the unit usable for homebuilt servers, NAS applications, or even just as a SAS expander. My target price for the entire kit would be around $200-250. I know this sounds like a lot but considering the quality of this case it is really comparable to other cases. Anyway, I put it to you guys to see if this would be something the community would be interested in. Let me know what your thoughts are. Thanks!
       
      Dan
       

    • By iSteve384
      somehow all my text got deleted.
      I basically need a large amount of power to run renders for blender, compressor, final cut and motion. 
      i can get an IBM Bladecenter with 14 HS20 blades cheaply, has anybody tried getting osx running on one of these or a similar system before?
      i have got osx running on a few pc's before, but never anything like this thing. 
       
      thanks in advance
      iSteve384
    • By sanric
      Salve a tutti,
       
      dal momento che sono entrato in possesso di un server DELL SC1425 ben carrozzato, volevo chiedere se qualcuno aveva già provato a montare su questa macchina una qualsiasi versione di OSX.
      Per chi non conoscesse la macchina, le caratteristiche sono disponibili su: http://www.dell.com/downloads/global/products/pedge/en/sc1425_specs.pdf
      Grazie a tutti per le cortesi risposte.
    • By enjoyfebruary
      I got a couple of used XServes for super cheap on eBay. I am going to use one as a VMWare Server for remote employees. The other will be a simple file server since I can do both SMB and AFP as opposed to our Win SBS 2011 server which can only do SMB. The one that will be for virtual machines I felt that I would need a little more power to handle the out of office employees. I bought a pair of Xeon e5345 CPUs for $40.00 on eBay and they certainly did the trick. Here are the before and after Geekbench results

      Before - http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench2/1814845

      After - http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench2/1533559

      Quite an improvement in my opinion. Went from four total cores to eight. As temps go; idle temps are around 35-42c. I also used Arctic Silver 5. OSX System Profiler does not recognize the CPU name. It gets the number of cores and speed right but it lists "Unknown" as the name. However, Geekbench and the virtual machines both see the CPU speed and name correctly. For $40 this was a great upgrade.
×