Jump to content
InsanelyMac Forum
Sign in to follow this  
Fire and Glass

Firewire Hiss Noise using Digi 003 Firewire Audio Interface

Recommended Posts

I am currently running a hackintosh in my studio with an Avid Digi 003 interface using firewire 400. Whenever I open Pro Tools and the firewire communication begins I get noise through my monitors. I am posting an audio sample of the noise. It is already happening at the beginning, then I should down pro tools, announce I am opening pro tools and as I click you can hear it breaks up the audio. This is really driving me nuts because I am trying to focus in on minute details in the audio and i cant with all this noise being so loud. Below is the hardware in using.

 

ASUS P7P55D-E Pro ATX Intel Motherboard

EVGA GeForce 9500 GT 01G-P3-N959-TR Video Card

Intel Core i7-860 2.8GHz LGA 1156 95W Quad-Core Processor

With a vanilla install of 10.6.3 updated to 10.6.4 using ######.

(I followed the guide on lifehacker)

 

I have read other forum posts on here with similar issue but most people were saying the noise was coming from the computer itself, and mine is coming through my monitors. If I cant find a solution through my current hardware I will try to purchase an external firewire card but I would rather save myself the $30 if I don't need it.

 

Thank you in advance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

Well my motherboard only has 1 firewire port so thats out of the question. I will look into the power supply but like I said being a brand new build I feel like its unlikely. I ordered a new firewire card off amazon yesterday so hopefully that will be the fix. I will post here after I install it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heh, yeah right. First rule of Hackintoshing is "know your hardware".

 

Like my Asus P5Q-E, your motherboard has two Firewire ports, one on the motherboard itself and one on the backplane. Maybe you should read your motherboard manual. I did.

 

It doesn't matter how new the build is if the PSU is badly isolated or cheaply made, or defective. The noise you're hearing is most likely caused by some kind of electrical interference, either from some component on the motherboard itself or from the PSU.

 

Think of it this way, if the CPU is the brain, then the PSU is the heart. Using a good quality PSU is very important, especially of you do more than surfing the web, checking email and running office apps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks for all the help guys. I read the manual but i missed what you were talking about. i now see the other 1394 port but i need to buy an adapter to access it. i just purchased an external pci-e firewire card off amazon and OSX read it no problem but I still have the sound, so it has to be something else. Sounds like my next step will be a better power supply, or should I spend time trying to organize and shield my wires inside the computer?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't worry about the wiring inside your PC, there's not much you can do about that. IF the problem is electrical interference AND indeed originates from inside your computer (you haven't established that yet), then it comes from either a component on the motherboard itself, or a component inside the power supply, not a badly insulated wire.

 

It's also possible that the noise comes from outside your computer, from an external source. Is the Digi 003 bus powered or does it use an external power brick? Is there any way you can try it on another computer? You need to verify that it is not defective.

Likewise, if the noise disappears when you're using the Digi 003 on Windows on the same PC then obviously it can't be a hardware problem.

You should take all possible troubleshooting steps first before throwing money at the problem - like you did - see how well that went...

 

My motherboard came with a PCI bracket and a cable that attaches to the internal Firewire port. Look in the box your motherboard came in, maybe it's hidden away there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

trust me the less money i spend to get this fixed the better. i just want the fastest fix possible.

 

the digi just uses a standard 3 prong power cable that all other devices uses, its power supply is internal.

 

i should have stated that my first trouble shooting procedure was that I have a macbook pro i connected my digi 003 to and the noise went away, so it has to be a problem with the hackintosh hardware (both the hackintosh and my macbook pro are running snow leopard with pro tools 9).

 

i reposted the audio sample to this reply since it didnt post originally.

Memo.mp3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You already know that the fastest fix possible is to use your MacBookPro when you want to make music.

 

Besides the constant hissing, the sounds that you hear after opening Pro Tools is the sound of your CPU and/or hard drive working. If you do some googleing you'll find that it is a common issue. Usually it's a simple grounding problem or a consequence of badly insulated or defective components in your PSU and/or motherboard.

 

Legend has it that in the 70's, way back when CPUs were much, much slower, there were programmers that were able to debug their programs by listening to that noise, the CPU was so slow that they were able to hear which part of the code it was executing.

Of course computers didn't have speakers at the time - this was done by placing a radio next to the computer and tuning it to a frequency that would pick up the noise.

This was later exploited to great effect, I don't remember the story but someone found a way to produce music, making the CPU execute a series of differently timed code loops, which the radio would then pick up. Not unlike how a modern sequencer works, thus bringing us back on topic.. :angel:

 

/EDIT *lol* I found some old dudes talking about it here: http://neil.franklin...gging_via_radio

 

The only way to be completely sure that it is a hardware issue, is to install Windows on your PC and try to use the Digi 003 with some Windows software. If the noise also appears in Windows, on the same hardware, then it is a software issue in OS X and not a hardware issue. If the same noise appears in Windows, then it is a hardware issue. If that is the case, I would start by investing in a high quality PSU. Or borrow one from a friend to test with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here are the things I have tried so far:

 

1. 3 Different firewire cables, exact same noise on all 3. The 003 has two fireports, i tried each cable on both ports, same noise

 

2. Bought the Syba 2 port PCI-E firewire card off amazon. Tried this with same 3 firewire cables, same noise on all cables, on both ports on the Syba firewire card and both FW ports on the Digi 003

 

3. Tried rerouting/organizing cables and seperating everything in side my tower and by my Digi 003. The same noise is still present

 

======================================================

 

Gathering what I can from this forum and tonymac86, there are only a few options left:

1. Ferrite beads on my cables

2. Power supply in the hackintosh

3. Motherboard in the hackintosh

 

I really dont think the problem is with the Digi 003 because when i connect it to my 2010 Macbook Pro, all noise is gone using the exact same everything.

 

I am really trying to tackle this in a process of elimination and cost effective way, so i really appreciate all the help your giving me, but im starting to get stumped. What do you think my next course of action should be?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I already told you what I think.

Before buying a new PSU or a new motherboard you should make absolutely sure that it's a hardware issue and not a software issue.

It's a Hackintosh, after all, you're not supposed to run OS X on your PC.

 

Grab any old hard drive and install Windows on it, XP or 7 will do. If the noise persists on Windows only then can you be sure that it's a hardware problem.

 

I'd first try plugging everything into a different power outlet in your house. Try unplugging everything from your PC that isn't necessary, including other expansion cards. Also try a different power cable for your PC.

 

If the noise persists, then I'd start looking for a new, high quality power supply. Read reviews here: http://www.hardwares....com/page/power

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Similar Content

    • By guitarsimo93
      Buon giorno a tutti ragazzi!
       
      Ho il mio sistema principale da dover aggiornare da Yosemite 10.10.5 a El capitan oppure a Sierra.
      Ecco l'hardware: MOBO: GA Z97-HD3 CPU: i5 4690 GPU: GT630
      Attualmente utilizzo clover per avviare anche un secondo ssd con installato windows.
       
      Sto verificando attualmente che tutti i programmi che utilizzo siano funzionanti su Sierra, ma vorrei valutare al meglio con voi se conviene aggiornare a Sierra oppure a El Capitan la mia work station.
       
      Se la memoria non mi inganna al momento dell'installazione di yosemite (e anche primo montaggio hardware), con il vostro aiuto, non ho avuto grossi problemi se non con la scheda video che o non riconosceva i 2GB di memoria che ha oppure causava il riavvio del computer anche quando schiacciavo su spegni o digitavo il comando da terminale per spegnere il computer.
      Ricordo che per risolvere il problema della scheda video avevamo lavorato parecchio sul dsdt.
      Kext particolari non ne ho installati (spero sempre di non dimenticarmi qualcosa) ho solamente quelli nella cartella di clover per la rete e per l'audio, mentre in Sistema/Libreria/Extension non mi ricordo di aver installato nulla.
       
      Una cosa che potrebbe creare qualche problema potrebbe essere la presenza (non più necessaria ma se riuscissimo a mantenerla sarebbe meglio) di una scheda pci per avere delle porte firewire. La scheda ha il chip principale della VIA. Ricordo che un annetto fa sulla build numero 2 e sulla numero 3 che potete leggere in firma, durante il tentativo di installarci El Capitan, non voleva funzionare e causava un kernel panic.
       
      Ecco la mia EFI completa ed attualmente in uso con yosemite:
      EFI Yosemite.zip
    • By guitarsimo93
      Buon giorno ragazzi!
       
      Qualcuno di vuoi saprebbe indirizzarmi sull'acquisto di una scheda pci con porte FireWire compatibile con El Capitan (10.11.3, bootloader Clover)?
       
      Grazie mille in anticipo a tutti quanti!
    • By guitarsimo93
      Buon giorno ragazzi,
       
      Ho necessità di utilizzare delle porte FireWire sulla seguente configurazione:
      Mobo: asrock b75m-gl R2.0
      Cpu: i7 2600k
      GPU: integrata HD3000
      Bootloader: clover v2.3 r3333
       
      In casa ho due schede FireWire che fino a Yosemite funzionavano anticamente senza bisogno di nessun kext o nessuna patch.
      Entrambe montano un chip FireWire della VIA siglato VT6306.
      La prima che ha solo la FireWire e quindi solo questo chip mi lascia avviare il computer ma non mi viene riconosciuta nessuna interfaccia FireWire.
      La seconda che ha quel chip per le FireWire e un secondo chip in aggiunta sempre della VIA e siglato VT6214L per delle usb aggiuntive mi fa riavviare il computer al boot. Ecco uno screen del riavvio
      https://www.dropbox.com/s/qh3e80gwgls616b/File%2016-02-16%2C%2018%2048%2015.jpeg?dl=0
       
      È possibile utilizzare in qualche modo una di queste due schede sotto El Capitan?
       
      Grazie ragazzi!
    • By kobe80
      Hi friends,

      So the other day i installed the newest updates for Yosemite. A bunch of things broke, but i got them all fixed, except firewire's not working. In System Report, it says 'No Firewire ports Available', and it won't detect my Apogee Ensemble FW audio interface.

      I know the card isn't dead bc in Windows, windows recognizes not only the card but the device i have plugged in (Apogee Ensemble FW Audio Interface - mac only)

      So the card seems fine. i tried different cables and ports on the card and ports on the ensemble.

      I also installed a fresh copy of Yosemite on another SSD and it's not working in that one either. I feel like maybe the software update from Apple killed the FireWire?

      Any ideas?


      My rig:

      5960X
      X99 Deluxe
      Yosemite
      Clover
    • By TheBosZ
      Ciao a tutti,
      è un pò di tempo che non mi faccio vivo su questo forum anche se capito spesso per leggere.
      Chiedo il vostro aiuto perchè sto preparando un Hackintosh ad utilizzo musica, quindi che presenti buone caratteristiche di gestione di grossi volumi di dati (sicuramente sotto i 16Gb non si andrà nella scelta).
       
      La mia domanda era quale scheda madre consigliate nella quale ci si debba mettere poco mano sopra in termini di kext e compagnia bella, in più il massimo sarebbe se fosse dotata di porte FireWire (il mio amico utilizza un mixer con questa connessione) e che anche in questo caso presenti pochi problemi nel riconoscere le periferiche attaccate.
       
      Se avete anche qualche topic da consigliare in lettura sono ben accetti suggerimenti,
       
      grazie mille per qualsiasi risposta
       
       
×