Jump to content
digivish

No Audio in Windows 10 with dual boot clover Catalina 10.15

13 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Hi All - quick thing - I have a NUC 8i7BEH with 32GB RAM and 2 x 1TB SSD drives. Each drive has its own OS - Windows 10 and Catalina 10.15.

 

Clover works well - Catalina Boots, so does Windows.

Catalina - has sound over HDMI (to my monitor's speakers)

Windows - no audio device found - It does show Realtek and Intel Display Drivers - but the speaker has a red"x" and in Devices, there is no entry for Microphone Array under Audio Input/Output. It does, however, show Intel display over the HDMI - but actually no sound.

 

I have tried reinstalling Realtek drivers - now here's the thing...when it installs, it first uninstalls existing Realtek drivers - at this stage (and it's important) the sound starts working - as if uninstalling did the trick. As part of the installing, I have to reboot and upon reboot, it actually reinstalls the Realtek drivers. After that, I'm back to square 1. Unsure if it's the config.plist or boot args in clover. But something with Clover for sure.

 

I have tested this by removing the Mac Drive with clover and just booting directly to Windows 10 bootloader and everything works as it should, I have sound over HDMI and the audio device shows. Just not when I boot with Clover.

 

has anyone experienced this and have thoughts or pointers.

 

Thanks a ton!

Edited by digivish
Added Tags

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

Very strange, I never saw it happen.

 

Does this also happen if you turn off macOS and turn on Windows through Clover? I'm talking about shutting down without rebooting.

 

Are you using AppleALC or VoodooHDA? Try switching to each other.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks - yes it's quite strange. Yes it does happen in both modes - restart and shutdown.

 

I have both kexts in my kexts/Other. I should try using one by one to see if it makes any difference.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But you can't use both at same time.

 

I don't believe that it's the cause, but you can try.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Erm... clearly the kexts you use to get audio in Catalina can have no impact in Windows. So switching from one to another is not going to change anything...

 

If you only lose audio in Windows when booting through Clover, it's obviously a Cover-related matter and you need to look into the Clover modules you've installed; I must admit it's very strange because what you describes leads to think that audio device is disabled in Windows and I've never heard of such impact from booting through Clover.

 

This being said, I suggest you state the version of Clover you use and the options/modules you installed so that we all know what you currently have.

 

Edited by Hervé

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

4 hours ago, Hervé said:

Erm... clearly the kexts you use to get audio in Catalina can have no impact in Windows. So switching from one to another is not going to change anything...

 

If you only lose audio in Windows when booting through Clover, it's obviously a Cover-related matter and you need to look into the Clover modules you've installed; I must admit it's very strange because what you describes leads to think that audio device is disabled in Windows and I've never heard of such impact from booting through Clover.

 

This being said, I suggest you state the version of Clover you use and the options/modules you installed so that we all know what you currently have.

 

Thanks. The Clover version is 5096 and a full dump is attached in the post above.

Edited by digivish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, digivish said:

 

Thanks. File attached.

 

 

debug_29748.zip

 

Just renaming AppleACL.kext to AppleALC-temp.kext doesn't disable it.

 

image.png.12dbe41bf86f0eae12c705457077dd87.png

 

Remove from the folder and try again. If it still doesn't work. Remove the VoodooHDA and put the AppleALC back.

 

Do both tests by removing CodecCommander just in case.

 

I don't particularly believe that this is your problem (two Kexts of audio at the same time), but it doesn't hurt to try ... Apart from that I found no problems with your files.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
42 minutes ago, ludufre said:

 

Just renaming AppleACL.kext to AppleALC-temp.kext doesn't disable it.

 

image.png.12dbe41bf86f0eae12c705457077dd87.png

 

Remove from the folder and try again. If it still doesn't work. Remove the VoodooHDA and put the AppleALC back.

 

Do both tests by removing CodecCommander just in case.

 

I don't particularly believe that this is your problem (two Kexts of audio at the same time), but it doesn't hurt to try ... Apart from that I found no problems with your files.

That didn't work. It's strange because in Windows 10, when I start Youtube, there is no sound and the video shows a playback error. Clearly some issue with the way drivers is getting screwy. 

 

Device Manager does not list Microphone Array (the NUC has a microphone) which has Realtek drivers. That has always been a clue for me to know if the sound will work or not. Whenever I reinstalled drivers (as described above) for the time before reboot, Microphone Array would show and then sound would work through the HDMI monitor and youtube would play.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All is well now. Seems like it was on the Windows side. I reinstalled the High definition Driver and Disabled Windows Update service.

 

Everything is sticking now and I have sound on both Windows 10 and Catalina.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But of course it was ! I couldn't even understand how people advised you to play with audio kexts in macOS to fix an audio problem in Win10 !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By ajmcello
      The following files exist on the github:
       
      a) Clover.app-v1.11-5100.zip
      b) Clover_v2.5k_r5100.pkg
      c) CloverISO-5100.tar.lzma
      d) CloverV2-5100.zip
      e) CLOVERX64.efi.zip
       
       
      Is (a) for installing as an app on OSX? What is it for?
       
      What is (b) for, the .pkg? Not exactly familiar with .pkg. I've seen it used in UNIX, but I believe it's also a PKG format for installing packages on OSX. So, what is the difference between this (b), and (a)? (a) is labeled v1.11-5100, while (b) is labeled v2.5k_r5100.
      (c) contains only this file, Clover-v2.5k-5100-X64.iso, which I assume is a pre-bootloader.
      (d) looks like the NON ISO version, to build an ISO?
      (e) Contains CLOVERX64.efi, which is the same CloverX64.efi for Clover.app-v1.11-5100 and CloverV2-5100.zip
       
      Thanks for any explanations. 
       

       
       
       
       
    • By Dolamarv
      Hi all, I have been using an x240 thinkpad for more than 2 months as hackintosh and it is very stable. As of now I am in Catalina 10.15.1 and it’s running great until I updated it to the new clover build r5100. My laptop won’t automatically sleep when I close the lid down now. I reverted back to 5099 and close-lid automatic sleep works. I don’t know what caused the problem but I think 5100 fixed a dsdt patching of some sort that that conflicted with my config plist? Thanks in advance!
    • By valueimagery
      Apologies ahead of time if this is in the wrong thread (please move to appropriate thread if necessary) as it applies to pre-installation and post-installation, Mojave and Catalina, motherboards, user preferences, but it's all related and I just had to get all this written down since it's all resolved...
       
      The issues:
      MOJAVE 10.14.6 2019 SECURITY UPDATE
      CATALINA 10.15.1 INSTALLER USB
      POST Mother Board UPDATE ISSUES
      UEFI Bootloader disappearing from BIOS boot menu/setup
      MAPS NOT WORKING/ CORRUPT USER/LIBRARY/CACHE
      GPT HEADER CORRUPTION AT BOOT
       
      This is my system which has worked flawlessly ever since 10.14.1 and automatic updates within the OS.
      10.14.6 iMac 18,3
      ASUS Rog Maximux X Code Bios v 2023
      Sapphire Nitro+ RX 580 Special Edition
      1 NVME System Drive, 1 x 1TB NVME Scratch Disk,  4 Internal 8TB HDD in raid 1+0, 4 x 3TB in a raid 5 setup with enclosure, 1 Backup System SSD, 1 2TB Time machine HDD (get to why I’m listing the drives later)
       
      Instead of making different posts for all of these issues that I’ve spent that past two weeks trying to solve (I almost gave up) I thought for anyone else out there experiencing one or any of the above issues you might find a solution in this thread.
       
      First let me say thanks to all the people out there in the various hackintosh communities (hackintoshers, tonymac, insanelymac, olarila, reddit) I researched every single one to find solutions for all these issues.
       
      Second, invest in Carbon Copy Cloner and make sure you make constant backups of your system drives.  Otherwise there would be no way to troubleshoot.
       
      So this all stemmed from not being able to update to Mojave 10.14.6 2019 Security Update released in November 2019.  
      My original post:
      Link removed:
      https://www.reddit.com/r/hackintosh/comments/e2naku/cant_update_mojave_to_security_update_2019001/
       
      There were plenty of different errors through troubleshooting:
      Kextdstall[1] (240s) ‘AppleACPICPU’
      or
      considerRebuildOfPrelinkedKernel com.apple.nke.webcontentfilter trigger rebuild
      or
      com.apple.xpc.launchd.domain.system
      <error>: Could not read path: path = /Library/LaunchDaemons, error=2: No suchfile or directory
      And
      IOG flags 0x3(0x51)

      IOConsoleUsers” gIOScreenLockState 3, hs 0, bs0, now 0, sm 0x0
      (The last two, still exist, but don’t stall/severely halt boot, and I’m not really sure if it’s an issue that needs to be addressed as I believe I’ve used the correct format of Device Properties to inject my framebuffer as a headless UHD 630 with 0x3E980003)
       
      Then once I managed to get past some of the installer stalls I always ended at “Installer resources were not found” prompting a restart and continuous loop cycle of no successful install.
       
      Then I tried making a bootable Catalina USB and couldn’t even install a fresh copy of 10.15.1 on a separate SSD.  Again getting errors in verbose mode that would stall and go no further.
       
      Then after cloning, and failing, and cloning and failing, changing bios settings, at some points my UEFI bootloader would completely disappear for my Samsung NVME 970 pro system drive.
       
      Was really getting frustrated, but was determined to fix it.  And here they are one by one in the order I Fixed them:
       
      Clover UEFI Bootloader Disapepared from Boot Menu
      So first I figured out what was going on with the UEFI bootloader disappearing.  I tried complete wipes of the APFS drive, Reinstalling Clover on the EFI partition.  Nothing.  Finally Found the solution here thanks to @chibabah
      Link removed:
      Tips:
      1)    If you have lots of connected drives use the Page Up and Page Down key to scroll through results of bcfg boot dump
      2)    Use Disk Utility or Terminal before hand to verify the exact UUID of your EFI system drive that has disappeared.
       
       
      Post Motherboard Update
      Now this seems to apply to a lot of people in the community who have updated and unknowingly couldn’t boot their system, or in my case, couldn’t update the current OS to the latest version.  This seemed to apply to my ASUS Maximus X Code v 2203.
      Thanks @mattystonnie for your ACPI patch found here:
      Link removed:
       
      Can’t Install fresh version of Catalina 10.15.1
      So after almost giving up on not getting the latest Mojave Security update, I wondered if Catalina would have the same issues.  Well it had different issues.
      Stall - Virtual IOReturn ionvmecontroller
      AppleACPICPU stalling
      Requiring EC device
      So I found this reddit thread thanks @dracoflar:
      https://www.reddit.com/r/hackintosh/comments/den28t/whats_new_in_macos_catalina/
       
      And applied the SSDTTime.command create by @corpnewt @noone @rehabman available here:
      https://github.com/corpnewt/SSDTTime
       
      The SSDT-EC.aml file it created from my DSDT.aml was the FINAL KEY in allowing the Catalina Installer to complete.
       
      Tips:
      1)    If you haven’t already created a SSDT before, for example a custom USB SSDT, it is placed in your EFI/Clover/ACPI/Patched/
      2)    In your config.plist under ACPI Check “AutoMerge” so that it is true.  This will automatically load any custom SSDT files from your patched folder.
       
      Apple Maps not loading
      This had been something that I had issues with before, more so with location services not working.  However, after several clones, and a succesful Catalina Install/User Migration, location services was fine, but Maps was a blank grey grid, couldn’t find an address, get directions, load satellite image.   Ended up being a corrupt User Library since other System Users had no issues using the application Maps.
      To fix this I used the following resources:
      https://appletoolbox.com/fix-corrupt-user-accounts-macos/
      1)
      Quit Maps
      Give Terminal Full Disk Access and the type:
      diskutil resetUserPermissions / `id -u`
       
      2)
      Deleting The Entire User Library Cache folder
      ~/Library/Caches
       
      3)
      Delete folder ~/Library/Containers/com.apple.Maps/
       
      4)
      Restart Mac.  All these caches and temporary folders will repopulated themselves and Maps should resume working.  
       
      Installing Mojave 10.14.6 2019 Security Update
      This by far is the craziest of them all.  Whether the above things I implemented to my EFI or config.plist actually played a part or not in it finally working I guess I’ll never know.  But it is finally solved.  Simply by unplugging all drives.  Appears to be an issue with real macs too:
      https://bartechtv.com/macos-could-not-be-installed-on-your-computer-error-when-installing-mojave-on-hackintosh/
      Link removed:
      Didn’t have to go the terminal route as some did in the tonymac thread above.
       
      So since I have A LOT of drives I simply turned off my external enclosure, physically unplugged by 2nd NVME scratch drive, and disabled the SATA connectors in the BIOS.
       
      Low and behold after two restarts the Security update completed without a hitch or stall.
       
      After install I re-enabled/ connected/turned on all my drives, an no issues.  
       
      This must be a Mojave issue as I didn’t need to do this when installing Catalina from a USB installer.
       
      GPT header corruption has been detected
      And lastly for anyone out there with an ASUS Maximus Motherboard that has updated to the latest BIOS.  There seems to be an issue with external drives plugged into the PC (mine is in the back USB C port)  During boot the PC can’t POST and forces user into setup.
       
      I know there is nothing wrong with the GPT partition as I’ve run multiple tests in windows and mac.  And it’s a known issue with other ASUS motherboard users:
      https://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?114955-GPT-header-corruption
       
      Temporary Solution:
      Until a BIOS update addresses this, go to your BIOS settings
      BOOT\Boot Configuration
      And change the Boot Sector (MBR/GPT) Recovery Policy to “Auto Recovery”
       
    • By kushwavez
      MOBO: GIGABYTE Z77P-D3
      CPU: Intel Core i7-3770 Quad (Ivy Bridge) 3,4 GHz
      RAM: 8 GB (4+4) KINGSTON 1333MHz
      Audio: HD Audio (ALC888)
      Ethernet: Realtek8111
      Graphics: HD 4000 and(or) RX 5700 8 GB
      SSD: KINGSTON 240GB SSDNow mSata
      HDD: 1: 500 GB SAMSUNG 2: 1 TB Western Digital
       
      Running: macOS Catalina 10.15.1 - Windows 10
       
      Bios settings:
      UEFI - ON CSM: Disabled AHCI Integrated Graphics: AUTO Primary Graphics: iGFX Memory: 1024M DVMT: MAX Working
      Everything (App Store, Messenger, FaceTime, etc.)  
      Not working
      For AirDrop and Handoff you need a compatible Broadcom Wifi+Bluetooth card. I bought a BCM94360 card with a PCI-E adapter, it's OOB. Currently waiting for arrive, will report back.  
      Issues
      Sometimes I hear crackling sound (just on Catalina 10.15.1, didn't happen on 10.15 or before) If you don't have this issue please let me know.  
      Before updating to newer versions, update your kexts! (and Clover if necessary)
      Generate a new serial with Clover Configurator
      Download the Clover folder: Z77P-D3-catalina.zip
       
      - SMBIOS: iMac13,2: iMac (27-inch, Late 2012)
      - ig-platform-id: 0x0166000b
       
      - There is no need for Whatevergreen.kext 
      - The HD 4000 is working with- or without a graphics card (headless with IntelQuickSync)
      - RX 5700 (ASUS RX 5700 GAMING OC 8 G) working OOB, just delete WhateverGreen.kext (causes black screen)
       
      Triple-Boot Win 10 and Linux (in my case it's Manjaro) (on one drive)
      Make sure your drive is in GPT and you're using UEFI If you have Win 10 installed then: Open diskmgmt (Disk Management), then Shrink your existing Win 10 partition to create two new for Mac and (if you want) for Linux If you have Mac installed: Create a new partition for Linux and (or) Windows in FAT Simply format that partition in Linux, Windows, or Mac installer, then install the OS Copy your working Clover folder to the system's EFI drive If it's automatically booting to Win, open cmd in administrator and write: bcdedit /set {bootmgr} path \EFI\CLOVER\CLOVERX64.efi That's it, automatically booting to Clover and you can select your OS If your Linux doesn't show up in Clover make sure you have GUI/Scan/Linux=Yes in config.plist  
      Mount your EFI on Windows:
      Open CMD in administrator and write: mountvol b: /s Use Explorer++ or TotalCommander in administrator to manage the folder Pictures:

       



    • By ezyrdr
      hallo hallo!
      I've been here on since snow leopard days, but still, im less than a rookie when it comes to hackintoshing! im just format it, copy it, install it dude-like! ahajajahaa sorry but I've been gettin this arb_buffer not present in my whatevergreen or don't know what OpenGL driver...steam games like Dying Light aren't playable since mojave 14.2 (no video, black screen) and several other opengl apps wont behave correctly at all...soo i only got you people to givme any idea of what am i doin wrong here with my installation, cause i got latest whatevergreen, as you could see from the capture im sending ... maybe i should go for a better video card?? i was thinkin buying a RX 590 8GB from Sapphire would kinda do de trick...but if a got a prob with my installation, most likely not uh!? ahaaja well thats from me for now, hope you guys are havin it this holidays with fam & loved ones, and are safe & witta rockin piece of hackintosh to play around with catalina, which is pretty cool system for me right now!
      HAPPY HOLIDAYS EVERYONE & BE SAFE!!!    ~_^

      ~edit~
      maybe i misconfigured ATI enabling in CloverEditor over the config file?!
×