Jump to content
InsanelyMac Forum

Recommended Posts

Hello everybody,

Within 2-3 weeks I want to buy my first Hackintosh. It's primary use will be music production (Logic X mostly). I've worked with Macbooks for many years but now it's time for a real workstation. Noise level is the most important part of this configuration (besides stability ofcourse), I really want this machine to be as quiet as possible.
 

  • Intel Core i7-4790
  • Scythe Big Shuriken 2 Rev. B
  • Gigabyte GA-Z87X-D3H or Gigabyte GA-Z87X-UD3H
  • Samsung 840 EVO 250GB (OS, apps)
  • WD Red 1TB or Seagate 7200.14 1TB (samples, projects, documents, etc.)
  • Asus GT640-DCSL-2GD3 - passive cooling
  • Cooler Master Silencio 452
  • 2x Crucial Ballistix Tactical 8GB DDR3-1600 CAS Latency 8, supported by both motherboards
  • Seasonic G-Serie 550Watt PCGH Edition
  • TP-Link TL-WDN4800
  • 2x Dell Ultrasharp U2412M Black, 1920x1200 each

This configuration will cost about 1450 euros in my country. I want to use Mavericks as it's primary OS, I won't switch to Yosemite until 10.10.3 or something like that. Here are some arguments and doubts about the components.

CPU and CPU Cooler
The 4790 is a little bit faster than the previous 4770 and costs the same, it's compatible with both motherboards. I'm used to dual-core processors, this will be my first quad-core so I'm really thrilled about this little monster! I don't want a passive cooler because it needs more airflow (thus more and louder casefans). I've read many reviews and this cooler should be the quitest.

Motherboard
The differences between the GA-Z87X-D3H and GA-Z87X-UD3H are: 2 SATA ports, 2 eSATA ports, Display Port and a different audio chip. All of those things don't really matter to me. 6x SATA is enough, I don't need a Display Port since I use a dedicated GPU and I won't use the onboard audio at all (I currenly use an Apogee Duet 2 and will buy a 19" interface later this year). I tend to go for the UD3H, not because of the extra features, but I found a lot more success stories with this board. I've read stories about the D3H where a beta BIOS is required to gain stability. I need the latest BIOS due to the Haswell Refresh CPU.

Storage
I can't choose between the WD drive the Seagate drive. The first seems more quiet but not exactly built for my needs, it's primary use is for NAS-systems. The Seagate seems noticeably faster but is also noisier. I have no idea "how much" noisier this drive will be.

Case and PSU
The Fractal Design R4 has been recommended many times and there are no reviews between this case and the Coolermaster I choose. The Coolermaster gets very positive reviews and I like the design better. The Seasonic is very efficient and must be very quiet. I'd love to hear suggestions for quiter PSU's, this is the best I could find.

Graphics and dual monitors
I guess 2x 1920x1200 won't be a problem for a Geforce GT640 2GB. I won't use it for heavy gaming or video editing or something like that. It's the fastest passive GPU I could find which is OOTB supported. I don't want to take any risk with buying a HD7750 or R7 250. 

 I'd love to hear your comments and suggestions. Thanks in advance!  ^_^

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Advertisement

My X79 build uses the R4 case. It's not bad but it feels a bit cheap in places. The plastic front door for one. The stock fans could be a bit quieter (I have them on the middle setting I think). For ages I had an annoying buzz that would show up often from inside. If I tipped it slightly in one direction it would stop. Eventually I wanted to get to the bottom of it as others had suggested it might be the bottom fan filter vibrating. I took out all the extra drive bays and that sorted it.

 

Overall the system is very quiet. The noisiest part is the hard disk. I went with a 2TB WD Black because I always use those for system disks. Just didn't realise how loud it would be inside a system built for quiet running. I thought about replacing it with a Blue or Green but it's not that big a deal right now. I've always stuck with WD drives and they've been great.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I made a major mistake with the CPU cooler. It turns out the Scythe isn't quiet at all! I'll swap it for a Noctua NH-U12S.

 

I'd go for a thunderbolt capable board, because of the newest thunderbolt interfaces from Universal Audio, such as the Apollo.

 

You're absolutely right but the Gigabyte motherboards with Thunderbold are very expensive. There are some cheaper Asus and Asrock boards but they require a modded BIOS.

 

 

Overall the system is very quiet. The noisiest part is the hard disk. I went with a 2TB WD Black because I always use those for system disks. Just didn't realise how loud it would be inside a system built for quiet running. I thought about replacing it with a Blue or Green but it's not that big a deal right now. I've always stuck with WD drives and they've been great.

 

Yesterday I've ordered a 3TB WD Red for my fileserver so I can listen to the noise and make a final decision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too, am about to put together a system very similar to yours for music production...primarily Logic X. I'm very much a novice in the Hackintosh world as I'm gathering information (much of it opinions) from various sources on the web. I do have a few comments on your item selections that maybe you and others can elaborate on:

 

Motherboard - I decided to go for the GA-Z87x-UD5H. It was on sale for less than your two choices. Also, it has firewire, though only 400 I believe, and it also has a 2 legacy PCI slots. In the music world, you never know, could come in handy when you least expect it. 

 

CPU - I've been told that the i7-4790 is not fully supported by OSX at the present time and that apparently wake issues may occur as a result. I have no idea if this is true. I have also been told that it runs cooler than the i7-4770 which is a plus. I'm undecided right now.

 

CPU cooler - Not sure why you're not going for the Noctua NH-D14. I could be wrong but I think it's even quieter than the NH-U12S. 

 

Graphic card - Asus GT640 - passive cooling. This is my choice, too. I was surprised to see this on your list as almost no one suggests it. But why not use the onboard video? From what I've gathered, the GT640 won't have any appreciable performance gain over the onboard video. The only reason I'm opting for the Asus GT640 is that I'm going to install two of them as I will be running six monitors in windows via a dual-booting configuration.

 

PSU - I have the Seasonic X series 650 on my list (SS-650KM). I think it might be quieter than the one you've chosen.

 

Case - I'm going with the Fractal Design Define XL R2. I got it at a great price. It's bigger than the R4 and has a few more options. I recommend, if you haven't already thought of it, to use all Noctua fans in whatever configuration of fans that you decide upon in your case.

 

Good luck! I hope you continue to post updates here as I will as well. I see that you also posted over at tonymac. I've posted there a few times recently with questions based on this particular configuration and didn't get much in the way of any beneficial responses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too, am about to put together a system very similar to yours for music production...primarily Logic X. I'm very much a novice in the Hackintosh world as I'm gathering information (much of it opinions) from various sources on the web. I do have a few comments on your item selections that maybe you and others can elaborate on:

 

Motherboard - I decided to go for the GA-Z87x-UD5H. It was on sale for less than your two choices. Also, it has firewire, though only 400 I believe, and it also has a 2 legacy PCI slots. In the music world, you never know, could come in handy when you least expect it. 

 

CPU - I've been told that the i7-4790 is not fully supported by OSX at the present time and that apparently wake issues may occur as a result. I have no idea if this is true. I have also been told that it runs cooler than the i7-4770 which is a plus. I'm undecided right now.

 

CPU cooler - Not sure why you're not going for the Noctua NH-D14. I could be wrong but I think it's even quieter than the NH-U12S. 

 

Graphic card - Asus GT640 - passive cooling. This is my choice, too. I was surprised to see this on your list as almost no one suggests it. But why not use the onboard video? From what I've gathered, the GT640 won't have any appreciable performance gain over the onboard video. The only reason I'm opting for the Asus GT640 is that I'm going to install two of them as I will be running six monitors in windows via a dual-booting configuration.

 

PSU - I have the Seasonic X series 650 on my list (SS-650KM). I think it might be quieter than the one you've chosen.

 

Case - I'm going with the Fractal Design Define XL R2. I got it at a great price. It's bigger than the R4 and has a few more options. I recommend, if you haven't already thought of it, to use all Noctua fans in whatever configuration of fans that you decide upon in your case.

 

Good luck! I hope you continue to post updates here as I will as well. I see that you also posted over at tonymac. I've posted there a few times recently with questions based on this particular configuration and didn't get much in the way of any beneficial responses.

 

According to this review the NH-U12S should be a little bit quieter! I also posted to a Dutch forum and they told me the Cooler Master V550 PSU is more quiet than the Seasonic at high levels. Another change I'm considering is the SSD. The Samsung 840 EVO serie doesn't support the 'powerloss' feature. The Crucial MX100 does, although it's a little bit slower. I'll keep you updated ofcouse :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You are most likely correct as it is smaller thus one would think should be quieter. I had looked at this review which had many of the results in their table appear to be a little suspect to me. Though is does seem to be a very thorough review.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Similar Content

    • By ITzTravelInTime
      KX AUDIO DRIVER MOD
       
      Hi guys i am a small developer, i really like to use my sound blaster cards on my machines and i love also coding, so when i find the source code for the kx audio driver on git hub and then Eugene, the creator of kx audio driver decided to no longer maintain the project, i decided to start working on a mod of this driver. 
       
      With my mod, created starting from the sources of the last version of kx audio driver, and also by using apple developer documentation for pci and audio drivers as reference, i am working to achieve 2 things mainly: get all the cards supported by the driver to work with all the recent versions os macOS and add support for other cards that are not officially supported by the driver that works or could, but needs to be more properly supported.
       
      This driver is made to support cards based on the E-mu 10k1, 10k2 and similars (like what is used by audigy rx and audigy 4 cards).
       
      Supported cards are:
       
       - most of the sound blaster live!, live! 5.1 and live! 5.1 digital series
       - sound blaster 512
       - sound blaster 256
       - other creative and e-mu sound cards based on the 10k1 chip (cards with the ES1370/ES1371/ES1372/ES1373 chips are not supported)
       - sound blaster Audigy series (1 st gen)
       - sound blaster Audigy 2  and audigy 2 zs series
       - E-MU cards based on the 10k2 sound chip
       - Some Audigy 4 cards (SB0610 only) and the audigy 4 pro
       - Sound blaster Audigy RX (sb0155)
       - other creative and e-mu cards based on the (10k2, 10k2,5 and CA10300 based cards)
       
      NOT supported cards:
       
       - Any ISA Sound card
       - ES1370/ES1371/ES1372/ES1373 based sound cards
       - CMI8738/CMI8788 based cards
       - Any CA0106 based card and cards with similar architectures (like sound blaster live! 24 bit, sound blaster audigy SE SB0570, audigy LS and similars, but audigy SA is supported)
       - Any sound blaster x-fi (some of them works on macOS using a modified version of voodoo hda)
       - Any sound blaster recon3D
       - Any sound blaster Z/ZS/ZX and similar series
       - Any sound blaster AE5 series
       
      In the time being the things i have modded or added with this mod are:
       
      - increased the simple buffer frames number with different values for emu10k1 based cards and emu10k2 based cards (including recent audigy 4 and rx) to reduce and all the audio cracking issues and possibly fixing all of them on a lot of cards
       
      - added a more proper support for the pci express sound blaster audigy rx (which basically is an audigy 4 with a pcie bridge chip) 
       
      - added more fancy names for the cards in the settings and other menus (so the name will be, for example, SB live! 5.1 SB0060 instead of kx SB0060 [e880] witch was shown in the original driver)
       
      - added support to sample rate chaning and added lots of sample rates (from 8 khz to 176,4 khz) to accomodate any possible usecase (note that 10k1 sound cards are limited up to 48khz sample rate, and 10k2 based cards for now are limited up to 176,4 khz and because of issues getting 192 khz to work, for now the driver goes up to 176,4 khz for supported cards) 
       
      - added boot args to manage the driver:
       
      Boot args to use with the kx audio driver mod: -kx_disable or -kxdisable or -kxoff This will prevent the driver from doing any initialization work, so the driver is basically disabled, use it to boot your ssytem in case the driver is giving you issues and kernel panics while you are trying to boot/using your system, so you are able to remove this driver or replace it with another version of it or to do some truble shooting. -kx_debug or -kxdebug or -kxspec Will show more debug info about the card, mainly the i/o port address and the kind of bus that it uses -kx_exp_deb or -kx_beta or -kxbeta Will enable experimental and probably not working or unstable features like showing inputs for the card or 192 khz sampling rate, use it only for testing and debug purposes, this may likely cause instability and problems in the everyday usage! Use it at your own risk! -kx_original or -kxoriginal This will basically turn off almost all the mods of this mod, so the driver will come to work as it was before modding it, this can be usefoul as a "safe mode" like feture to have a working driver in case of problems with features of the mod, so using this means no crsking issues improvements, only 48 khz sample rate and only features of the non-modded kx audio driver for mac os x  
      - created a script file to use with the driver for debug and also installer replacement, it can be also used to unload and reload, replacement of the driver without rebooting
       
      What i'd like to implement but i don't know how to do:
       
       - I'd like mainly to add a more proper support to the pci bridge chip of the audigy rx,
       
       - have audio inputs working,
       
       - fix the support when using more than one card, to get all the cards shown in the settings and other menus,
       
       - have the gameport/gameport midi port of older cards to be used in mac os as a midi in/out
       
      If other developers would like to join and help me, you can, and also an hand from other people with testing and feedback will be nice.
       
      link for the kext only (if you have clover put it in [your clover efi folder]/clover/kexts/[your macOS version]/ so it will not be deleted when updating macOS):
               - download from the downloads section:          kX Audio Driver Mod by ITzTravelInTime 1.01                                                                                    - external download:                                      https://dl.dropboxus...Driver.kext.zip   link for the installer pack (the best way to install it, but you have to reinstall it when you upgrade macOS, remeber to fix kext permitions and rebuild the kernelcache if you want to remove the kext from it's install directory without using the unistall feature of the provvided script):              - download:                                                   https://dl.dropboxus...aller pack.zip   Source code from Git Hub:          -  github repo:                                               https://github.com/ITzTravelInTime/kx-audio-driver   NOTE: Some system because of some problems with the HPET may need to use FixHPET in clover and to install the kext in /System/Library/Extensions  






    • By ITzTravelInTime
      This driver is a mod of the popular kx audio driver for mac os x, the project goal is to still maintaining it for the future releases of mac os and to include as much cards as possible and to get all the features of the cards to work.
       
      Currently the only features not supported are audio inputs and integrated midi and synth capabilitues of the cards, and some minor things like creative remote controllers or software controlled volume gears on creative external drives and bays)
       
      It supports most the sound blaster live! series cards, the sound blaster PCI 512, most of the audigy (emu 10k2 based) series, audigy 1, audigy 2, audigy 2 zs, audigy 4 (SB0610), audigy 4 pro, audigy 5 and audigy rx (sb1550) and some e-mu edsp audio cards with all the recent versions of mac os, tested to work with mac os yosemite, el capitan, sierra and high sierra on intel based machines from socket 775 to 1151 (including enthusiast platforms like x58, x79, x99, x299) and also confirmed to work on mac pros.
       
      reference topic:
       
      Kx audio driver mod [sound blaster live!, audigy 1/2/4/RX emu edsp]
    • By oliveiro
      Hi community !
      Is anybody successful with 10.13.x and multiple GPUs on a desktop hack ?
      My main rig (see in signature) HD4600 + GTX550Ti + GTX560 is working perfectly under 10.11.6 and 10.12.6.
      Very simple to install, Intel IGPU set to active and primary in bios, inject intel and igplatformid in bootloader (enoch or clover), no nividia injection, since Fermi GPUs are natively supported. Smbios set to iMac14.2 for my Haswell CPU, and to avoid AppleGraphicsDeviceControl devices unloading.
      But from 10.13.0 to 10.13.3, system boots fine until login screen where WindowServer crashes with a "no MTLDevice" error (MeTaL device I guess). I could workaround that error by unloading nvidia devices in AppleGraphicsDeviceControl, but that kind of defeats the purpose, since only the IntelHD4600 can then be used.
      10.13.4 brings a little improvement, desktop can be reached, all 3 gpus active (AppleDisplay instances appear in IORegistryExplorer for Intel and Nvidias) but only Intel HDMI output shows desktop correctly, both nvidias (HDMI or DVI output) only show a black desktop where the mouse pointer can be moved normally. Displays can be arranged, orientation and resolution can be changed, as if everything was fine, but it is not.
      Console shows the following repeated messages :
           WindowServer (Skylight) : Unable to composite display surface due to null compositor.
           WindowServer (CoreDisplay) : [ERROR] - Attempting to get capabilities from capabilities with no devices
      Does anybody have an idea on how to avoid or workaround these errors ?
      Thanks !
      O.
      Things I've tried:
      Bios Graphic Devices order changes (breaks everything unless IGPU is primary) nvidia injection in bootloader (fails in enoch, disables secondary nvidia GPU outputs in clover) Smbios changes and/or AppleDeviceControlPolicy plist edits (simply enables or disables nvidia outputs) nvidia official or web drivers (no changes at all, even though webdrivers are properly loaded ; requires nvram emulation with enoch) enoch or clover (no difference except clover boots a bit faster - than enoch with nvram - thanks to proper UEFI boot I guess) lilu intel and/or nvidia and/or coredisplay graphicsfixups (no visible changes but graphics devices names, and thus enables or disables AGPM) use binaries from Sierra 10.12.6 for CoreDisplay and/or Skylight frameworks (never reached desktop) NVIDIAeGPUSupport (no changes)
    • By Angelo_
      HI, i've installed high sierra a while ago and never really used it that much but i got bored of w10 so i've decided to use it as my daily driver for a while and i noticed that usb 3.0 ports don't work with usb 3 devices and only with usb 2.0 devices(capped at the 480mb/s limit of usb 2.0), is there a way to get past that? i couldn't find it in this forum, i don't need the speed that much for right now(even tho i might since i shoot in raw and usb 2.0 is slow for file transfer of big photos or videos i take on holidays or on days off)  but i'd like to at least be able to use the usb 3.0s with my usb 3 devices and hub. 
      Hope that i write this post correctly, english is not my main language.
      ps  i don't need because i'm on lan but does it exist a driver/kext for intel wifi/bluetooth combo integrated in my z87 mpower(centrino 2200) ? bluetooth works already.
    • By spectra
      Hi people, can someone help to put my HDMI sound working? I already tried different methods and I can't figure a way to fix this problem.   And another question, someone knows why the HDMI port just work if i use macbook pro 14,2 on smbios? Because my hardware is much more similar to 14,3.    
      thanks guys
      My system dump
      CLOVER.zip
      DarwinDumper_3.0.4_01.02_12.24.51_MacBookPro14,2_AMI_X64_4392_High Sierra_17D47.zip
×