Jump to content
3 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

I came across this whilst researching external Firewire soundcards/interfaces. This isn't a compatibility list but these sorts of devices usually have Mac drivers, some of the brands are even sold on the Apple store.

 

Gearslutz - least reliable firewire interface

 

Ranking position calculated on number of satisfied customers (score of 1) minus number of dissatisfied customers (score of 2 or 3)

From best to worst:

 

RME(18-0) = 18

Echo(19,1) = 18

Motu(20,5) = 15

Mackie(11,2) = 9

Tascam(7,0) = 7

Alesis(3,2) = 1

Presonus(10,11) = -1

Focusrite(4,9) = -5

M-Audio(8,26) = -18

 

Alternative ranking position calculated on number of satisfied customers divided by total number of customers

 

RME 100%

Tascam 100%

Echo 95%

Mackie 85%

Motu 80%

Alesis 60%

Presonus 48%

Focusrite 31%

M-Audio 24%

 

That's a *minus* 18 score for M-Audio. :(

Link to comment
https://www.insanelymac.com/forum/topic/152303-firewire-external-audio-devices/
Share on other sites

I have no experience with M-Audio's FireWire H/W, but I know from long experience with an Audiophile24/96 card that their drivers suck.

 

The MOTU drivers aren't terribly user friendly but they mostly work. This is from experience with an 896 and a pair of 8pre units. I haven't yet found why I will sometimes get dropouts when recording multiple tracks live in Logic Express.

I have no experience with M-Audio's FireWire H/W, but I know from long experience with an Audiophile24/96 card that their drivers suck.

 

The MOTU drivers aren't terribly user friendly but they mostly work. This is from experience with an 896 and a pair of 8pre units. I haven't yet found why I will sometimes get dropouts when recording multiple tracks live in Logic Express.

 

mildly unrelated, but on the note of *internal* m-audio stuff:

 

Their "Revolution" drivers aren't so bad, and someone makes osx86 drivers for some of the cards from that series. They sound *really* nice.. OS X drivers are just basic i/o (stereo), but if you game it's a great card!

 

 

the dude has his OS X drivers at: http://www.audio-evolution.com/drivers/

×
×
  • Create New...