Jump to content
10 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Oh, now I see its a little bit complicated with the compatibilty then I thought. Thanks for the reply.

 

TheDelock card is a FW800 and a little bit expensive and not in stock.

 

I have found this DeLOCK 89121, 2x FireWire extern/1x FireWire intern, PCIe x1. Its FW400, cheap and in stock. Hmmm.. Any thoughts? It is not mac certified, but neither is the 89153.

 

Also from what I've read, PCI-X cards should be less of a problem than PCI, meaning there is a better chance it will work. Am I right? I'm a newbie.

Just curious- your graphics card blocks BOTH PCI slots? It must be enormous.

 

PCIx cards don't necessarily work better than PCI for Firewire. In each case, it depends on the chipset of the card being OSX-compatible. In fact, I think PCIx is a bit of a waste for FW 400 since the PCI interface handles it just fine, and PCIx cards tend be be more expensive [and judging by user reviews, crappier].

 

Here's a list of newegg PCIx FW cards- I'd only trust the models that specifically say they're Mac-compatible, the first being a StarTech for $37. (Lousy one-egg rating also).

 

By comparison, OSX-compatible PCI models are plentiful and dirt cheap.

Well, it blocks one ompletely and the other partialy. I believe I could squeeze a PCI card in, but it would bend a little. It is a standard dual slot cooler (MSI 8600 GTS).

 

Hm, now I'm confused, I wanted to buy DeLOCK 89121 tomorow, but it is not certified for OSX. The 89153 is neither but it works. I'm buying the card in austria and none of those fancy cards you listed is aviable here ;)

Damn, the 89153 is actualy mac osx certified. I don't know what to buy. It is too expensive and all the cheaper cards are officialy not supported, but that doesn't necessary mean they won't work.

 

How can I check if my system sees the PCI ports?

I can buy stuff from belkin, digitus, delock. dawincontrol and thats basicaly it...

I don't know if this helps you much but I am running a Syba SD-FWB-32B on a Gigabyte board. I just plugged it in the PCI slot and it showed up natively in both my Vanilla install and my iDeneb 10.5.5 install. I got my card for about $10 less at Freys, but it's the same card. So at least you know this one will work. I don't know of a diagnostic through the OS on the PCI ports other than trying the port.

 

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx...N82E16815124026

 

 

Damn, the 89153 is actualy mac osx certified. I don't know what to buy. It is too expensive and all the cheaper cards are officialy not supported, but that doesn't necessary mean they won't work.

 

How can I check if my system sees the PCI ports?

I can buy stuff from belkin, digitus, delock. dawincontrol and thats basicaly it...

Ok, I took the risk and bought the card Delock 89121. Even though the official site and package don't say anything about mac compatibility, it WORKS like a charm!!! :)

 

Delock 89121 - works on 10.5.6 - without any patches

It's a 3x firewire (2x extern, 1x intern) PCI-E card with TI chipset.

  • 1 month later...

The Delock 89121 seems only available in Europe. Apart from that, I suggest never to buy a mere FW400 card, if one has to buy one. The double-speed FW800 only costs a few bucks more. It is really not worth saving these few bucks, looking at the more-of-speed you get. If you do not yet have a FW800 HD, you have the option to get one in the futrue.

 

From reading and researching, if you live in the US I suggest (prices from NewEgg):

 

PCI: SYBA SD-FWB ($37) or StarTech PCI1394B ($43)

 

PCIe: SYBA Low Profile SD-PEX30009 or StarTech PEX1394B3

×
×
  • Create New...