QUOTE(Paranoid Marvin @ May 2 2008, 04:33 PM)

I'm sure it's not the organisation itself that is resorting to thug tactics. I'm not supporting what they did, just saying to look at it from a wider viewpoint,
The organization is the only thing it can be. People are taught to reduce the value of human life, especially to those that they will be fighting, this also has the unintentional effect of translating to the citizens of the people one is going to fight (Japs, Commies, Jews, Unholy, etc.). These labels are pinned on people in the hopes that the soldiers fighting them will see them as less human, or less worthwhile, and it works. This is why historically, soldiers occupying countries typically rape and pillage like crazy, there's nobody there to stop them and they have the power, and they have the dehumanization, it all adds up. Logically anyway.
QUOTE(A Nonny Moose @ May 2 2008, 03:28 PM)

Way to take a topic and make it into a US-bash. It seems like everything bad in the world has an example from the US, especially on message boards like this one. This might be because the US is an insanely powerful country that makes the news when it farts, or it might be because people have a axe to grind with George W. Bush, or it could be that people just don't like the US. Take your pick, they are each viable choices.I think we should be surprised that a PEACEKEEPING organization has resorted to thug tactics, no matter who is working the "thugging." That certainly isn't peacekeeping, and I think we can all agree on that. I think we can all agree that it's because someone was put in a position of power and took advantage of it. It's just that the US-bashing is getting really tired and really old.
I am not taking the topic and turning into a US-Bash. I was specifically referring to soldiers in general, including American soldiers. This is exactly what I have been talking about in previous posts about how soldiers in our minds are put into this different "semi-holy" category of "don't talk ill about any of them, they served their country, therefore they are good people". That argument might sound good but in terms of arguments it doesn't really hold a lot of water. I live in the US, so I talk about the US a lot because I understand it the most. I don't really want to talk much about Iran, Iraq, etc. because to be honest, I don't know as much about these countries as I would like. I have not been there, I have not seen how the people have been treated (by their own governments and by us) so on these issues I try to be prudent about the other side.The US isn't special, an American life has the same value as an Iranian, or an Iraqi life. There is NO real difference between us. The thing we lack is common ground culturally. This is what needs to be addressed. Invading countries and taking their $hit is not the way to improve these weak cultural associations.I love the US, I have lived here all my life. There are many unique things about this country that should be cherished by all. But I am not blind, I will see the US through a realistic scope, encouragement where deserved and anger where deserved. I am not loyal to any flag, border, or one specific person. I am only loyal to my fellow human beings and will follow/lead whoever is doing the right thing, whether they are from this country or not. Common ground is a lot closer than people think. Logic is needed to FIND this common ground.
The reason why this country is so Criticized is BECAUSE we are the big fish. As soon as China, or some other power surpasses us, THEY will be the target of the world's gaze. Because we are at the top (power wise) we are obligated to lead by example.