Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Linux is Not Windows
InsanelyMac Forum > Discuss and Learn > *nix
Kane Adams
If you've been pointed at this page, then the chances are you're a relatively new Linux user who's having some problems making the switch from Windows to Linux. This causes many problems for many people, hence this article was written. Many individual issues arise from this single problem, so the page is broken down into multiple problem areas.

Read it if you like.
Suprjacob
That's actually written really good.
S.SubZero
Users jumping head-first into Linux without a real understanding of it is one issue. The other issue is wildly overzealous Linux fanboys who prosylitize and tell unsuspecting users that Linux is the greatest thing ever and MIKKKRO$$$$HAFT SUXXXX on every possible opportunity.
solaar
The biggest fallacy is actually the constant 'comparing' of Linux with Windows itself. Two OSes whose underlying base is fundamentally different (AFAIK).

I never quite understood why the Linux community keeps stubbornly 'pointing down' to messy Windows. How about pointing up? Why isn't the more obvious brought more to the front, ie. OSX? That's at least a more appropriate candidate in direct comparison than Windows, technically speaking, roughly at least. Also I reckon (in my fairly limited technical knowledge) that OSX would be the better template in trying to 'recruit' a new audience, along the lines of 'our distro is even easier than OSX'.

Win... say what?
Alessandro17
QUOTE (S.SubZero @ Oct 9 2008, 02:56 PM) *
Users jumping head-first into Linux without a real understanding of it is one issue. The other issue is wildly overzealous Linux fanboys who prosylitize and tell unsuspecting users that Linux is the greatest thing ever and MIKKKRO$$$$HAFT SUXXXX on every possible opportunity.


I agree. It is basically what I wrote here:

http://forum.insanelymac.com/index.php?sho...128347&st=9


QUOTE (solaar @ Oct 9 2008, 03:39 PM) *
I never quite understood why the Linux community keeps stubbornly 'pointing down' to messy Windows. How about pointing up? Why isn't the more obvious brought more to the front, ie. OSX? That's at least a more appropriate candidate in direct comparison than Windows, technically speaking, roughly at least.


Maybe because OS X isn't just an OS that you buy and install on your existing hardware?
solaar
QUOTE (Alessandro17 @ Oct 9 2008, 04:24 PM) *
Maybe because OS X isn't just an OS that you buy and install on your existing hardware?

Well, that shouldn't stop anybody from making a Linux distro that's as user-oriented and noob-friendly out of the box as OSX, should it? With all the flexibility Linux has to offer it should be far from being an impossibility. Why does it always have to be just as 'user-friendly' as Windows?

Be bold - be better than the best... shouldn't that be the slogan?
mmcnally
Be Ubuntu
Alessandro17
QUOTE (solaar @ Oct 9 2008, 05:45 PM) *
Why does it always have to be just as 'user-friendly' as Windows?


Maybe because Windows does a pretty good job in terms of user-friendliness? (it sucks from every other point of view, we know it, but that is another matter).

And besides I find KDE3 even more user-friendly than Windows (KDE is not the entire OS, I know it).
SDRacer48
QUOTE (solaar @ Oct 9 2008, 01:45 PM) *
Be bold - be better than the best... shouldn't that be the slogan?


If only the other 99.9% of the world thought like that, who knows what could be accomplished...

sigh
Paranoid Marvin
Well written article - love the penultimate paragraph though:

QUOTE
If you really want the security and performance of a Unix-based OS but with a customer-focussed attitude and an world-renowned interface: Buy an Apple Mac. OS X is great. But don't get Linux: It will not do what you want it to do.

tongue.gif
Alessandro17
Linux does what you want it to do if you have a clue. It always did for me.
Of course if you need to use applications not available in Linux it is always better to run another OS. That is simple common sense.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.